Good Effing God - open classrooms. Yep ... we've never seen that tried before. How long will it take before they bring in the walls to divide up the space so that kids can think again?
The New Math was kind of like the Great Leap Forward of mathematics instruction - realizing that schools were stuck in out-of-date, low-productivity methods of the past, educators decided to jump into the future all at once, a huge change for which neither students nor teachers were prepared, with catastrophic results. Nevertheless if you look at at material that was actually introduced to replace old mechanical methods of multiplication and division and so on - the subject-matter that was ridiculed by every senator and talk-show-host - it is striking how much more useful it is in today's STEM fields than multiplication and division. Set theory, modular arithmetic, symbolic logic, Boolean algebra - all of these are useful, and often necessary, for a career in Computer Science, for example. Multiplication and division are for calculators.
The problem with the New this and New That is the mostly inadvertent disposal of the benefits which accompany the old and the old ways
Some of the real problems which we have today are:
Innumeracy -- the equivalent of illiteracy applied to things mathematical
the core of science is math -- often simple math -- i.e. the proverbial "back of the envelope calculation"
lack of the understanding of the basis of science
Newton's Laws
Bernouli's Principle
very simple electricity
very simple electromagnetics -- inverse square law
and a handful of more etc.
We live in an amazing era:
Daily we hear about "science fiction-like breakthroughs," amazing inventions, and new policies involving science and technology
Yet fewer and fewer of the people doing the reporting, editing, reading the news, or making the policy have any clue whatsoever is involved.
In general the public is unqualified to evaluate what is being presented to them..
Society depends on a "thin veneer" of science and technically competent to keep it running
The process of remedying this begins with exposure early on with skills such as:
estimating [e.g. calculating without a calculator],
common sense,
practical experience with stuff
unfortunately these are not popular in the modern STEM curriculum
The above are much much more important than glass, steel or even 3D printers although the mention of the latter is the most important information about the new STEM Academy which I've seen so far in the media hype
And yet some neighbors tried to NIMBY this under the guise of 'historic preservation' of the long-outdated and obsolete building there before. Check the @SavetheDearborn Twitter handle.
Comments
Sounds like a great curriculum
I hope they have great success with it, and that some of their innovations catch on elsewhere.
Clarification - first new BPS school
Brooke Charter High School (I think) is already open as of this month on American Legion.
Yep
Thanks, changed. There have been several charter schools that have opened in the past 15 years.
One fairly unequivocal good about charters
I think is the ability to pull in outside funding sources to build new free public schools for city kids to attend.
Good Effing God - open
Good Effing God - open classrooms. Yep ... we've never seen that tried before. How long will it take before they bring in the walls to divide up the space so that kids can think again?
Next up: the New Math, and Whole English!
Nope
The presence of windows and a lack of walls are two different things.
New Math
The New Math was kind of like the Great Leap Forward of mathematics instruction - realizing that schools were stuck in out-of-date, low-productivity methods of the past, educators decided to jump into the future all at once, a huge change for which neither students nor teachers were prepared, with catastrophic results. Nevertheless if you look at at material that was actually introduced to replace old mechanical methods of multiplication and division and so on - the subject-matter that was ridiculed by every senator and talk-show-host - it is striking how much more useful it is in today's STEM fields than multiplication and division. Set theory, modular arithmetic, symbolic logic, Boolean algebra - all of these are useful, and often necessary, for a career in Computer Science, for example. Multiplication and division are for calculators.
I remember my parents went to
I remember my parents went to a class so they could learn the "New Math" that we were being taught in school.
Dad was the homework helper and appreciated the class.
Need for Both Old & New Math, Physics, etc
The problem with the New this and New That is the mostly inadvertent disposal of the benefits which accompany the old and the old ways
Some of the real problems which we have today are:
We live in an amazing era:
The process of remedying this begins with exposure early on with skills such as:
unfortunately these are not popular in the modern STEM curriculum
The above are much much more important than glass, steel or even 3D printers although the mention of the latter is the most important information about the new STEM Academy which I've seen so far in the media hype
NIMBYs
And yet some neighbors tried to NIMBY this under the guise of 'historic preservation' of the long-outdated and obsolete building there before. Check the @SavetheDearborn Twitter handle.
What about STEAM?
What about STEAM?