Hey, there! Log in / Register
City-council candidate claims Black Lives Matter set race relations back 50 years
By adamg on Wed, 10/25/2023 - 12:35pm
At-large candidate Bridget Nee-Walsh made the comments at a forum organized by Boston Caribbean-Americans - drawing a rebuke from incumbent at-large Councilor Ruthzee Louijeune, who is herself Haitian-American.
Neighborhoods:
Topics:
Free tagging:
Ad:
Comments
She gives away her position
Nee-Walsh said:
You know that she was one of the simpletons saying "All lives matter" as a rebuttal which ignored the obvious fact that the slogan means "Black lives matter too.
Divided communities, or exposed the existing divisions?
Lots of people don't seem to understand that distinction.
Also, I actually love that "too" phrasing, and have somehow never heard it before. I kind of like it more, honestly?
Respectfully disagree
I think that black lives matter as a phrase is powerful because it’s divisive, it causes people like Bridget Nee-Walsh to show their true colors (while also explicitly pointing to the systematic, racist threats to Black lives). Adding the “too” is like saying “all lives matter:” it’s wishy-washy, big and meaningless.
I guess I read the "too" differently
although I can see where you're coming from on it.
(Partly I like it because you would no longer be able to change "black" to "all" and have it sound meaningful.)
Not "too"
That relegates Black lives to an afterthought, a second place. "Oh yes, we forgot about you! your lives matter too, sometimes, when it's convenient."
Yikes!
Given the presence of a few total lunatics in the race, I was uneasily considering voting for her, but I guess that's out the window now.
People who are uneasy with a fairly simple, straight forward illustration that racism is a problem in this country, are probably racists themselves.
If it helps you decide
“All lives matter” karen also thinks we need hundreds more cops.
https://www.bostonglobe.com/2023/10/17/metro/boston-city-councils-at-lar...
Her comments
Are worth quoting.
Given the chance to clarify:
Goodbye Karen.
Yikes on bikes
Covid happened 8+ years after BLM formed. Also, talking about racial divisions in this country in the past tense is, uh... well, it's certainly a choice, that she made.
Bonus historical idiocy: "50 years back" is quite the statement. I wonder if she's even aware of what happened in 1968..?
Translation
"I, a white person, am used to being able to ignore the reality of racism because it doesn't affect me, and so when it is pointed out that racism is indeed a real problem, my defensive reaction is to blame the people who mentioned it rather than the people who did it."
the dishonesty must be faced.
Our society does not demonstrate care for all races equally. We can't fix that until we admit that.
Nananana
Nananana
Hey hey hey
Clarification
What she meant to say was that it had taken us 50 years to get them to stop complaining and now they've gone and gotten all uppity again.
What are race relations?
Asked tongue in cheek. Everybody knows what they don't we? Or what gets in the way of improved race relations between Blacks, Browns and White, especially considering that race relations with Asians seem much better than a century ago and thank goodness race relations between the Jewish and Christian races are nowhere near as bad as a century ago. For that matter race relations between Protestants and Catholics have gotten much better as well.
Again written with tongue in cheek.
Race is probably one of the longest lasting and most deeply believed results of a propaganda campaign of the past 500 years ago. There is no such thing as human races.
The statement sounds academic and irrelevant in the real world. But maybe relevance can be sen by asking whether continuing to use the word actually reinforces the false idea. By reinforcing the falsity of human races it is easier to not see that real motivations behind what we call, for lack of better word, racism.
From the Smithsonian National Museum of African American History & Culture:
It is
Because it is.
"If people define situations as real, they are real in their consequences."
Confusion
There are some who think that, because race is a fiction, racism is also a fiction. This is a misunderstanding. Race is a fiction; racism is real.
"Black LIves Matter" isn't,
"Black LIves Matter" isn't, and wasn't about race relations. It was about Police Officers indiscriminately killing Black people at will on the slightest pretext and usually getting away with it all across America. A pandemic of sorts that still goes on, but the "Black LIves Matter" movement made consequences for those actions a real thing to Police again.
Corollary
Blue lives matter is a response to Black Lives Matter, an explicit rejection of BLM’s contention that police shouldn’t be allowed to indiscriminately kill black people. Which is to say: blue lives matter is explicitly racist.