Hey, there! Log in / Register
Walsh signals no change in space-saver policy
By adamg on Tue, 01/27/2015 - 6:25pm
Mayor Walsh said today:
If you spend 10 hours shoveling out a space, it's your space for a couple of days.
Neighborhoods:
Topics:
Free tagging:
Ad:
Comments
Signals? I would say that's an outright endorsement.
Good luck, street parkers. It's going to be ugly for a good long while since it's not going to warm up anytime soon, this storm is not quite over (have a look at the bands on the radar as of 6:39p) and there is more accumulating snow on the horizon for Thur nite/Friday and again Sun nite/Mon.
Eeek.
What?
Who is spending 10 hours to shovel out a space? I shoveled out my snow-drifted sidewalk, front walk, and a parking space sized section of the street to have access to the house. In total I'd estimate this is an area about 6 times the area of a normal parking spot. Took me maybe 2 hours between going out a few times.
isn't that the point?
I read it as a sarcastic comment. Reworded: "sure, it's yours, if you spent 10 hours shoveling it out."
Older or disabled people on a
Older or disabled people on a fixed income who can't afford someone to dig out their car, maybe?
Huge mistake.
Few spend more than an hour and an hour's labor is the cost of parking on street instead of a garage. those who don't space save won't find a spot because someone will stick a cone where they shoveled.
Bring on the squatting of public land, intimidation, and worse...
Eventually when some moron
Eventually when some moron kills someone over a space saver Marty is going to have blood on his hands for endorsing this juvenile bullshit. The level and frequency of violence and vandalism related to space savers has been steadily escalating and it is only a matter of time.
What an idiot
What an idiot
And if you spend 10 months crafting an Olympic Bid....
It sounds like the same reasoning applies to taking over the city to host the Olympics, just because you spent time applying for it.
Mayor Trash Bag.
Mayor Trash Bag.
Disappointing
I thought we were done with that shit when Menino retired.
How in the hell can an elected official actually justify, a: hoarding more than you need of a scarce public resource, and b: squatting on public land?
I thought we were done with
Really?
Doing it wrong
Anyone saying it takes more than 45 min to dig out their space is either lying, or waited until it was frozen into a block of pure ice like a cartoon character.
This is easily the space saver version of walking up hills both ways through the thundersnow.
Time to shovel a space
I shoveled out three spaces today. The first two took over an hour (they were together) and the last one took close to two hours. First every shovel full had to be carried about 20 feet and second the spot was loaded with snow from plowing and people dumping snow from other places into it. Certainly more than half the spot was over 3 feet deep when I started. The spot where I dumped the snow had snow up to about 5 1/2 feet.
15-20 min
Given what I see out my window most people spent about 15 minutes. Most people don't give a shit and just throw the snow back out onto the street or sidewalk until there is just enough space for their car to inch in or out.
Maybe the 10 hours includes finding something to put in the spot and messing with whoever had the nerve of parking in "your" spot.
I spent 15 minutes shoveling
I spent 15 minutes shoveling my car out and the sidewalk in front of my condo in the morning, and then another 15 minutes in the evening. My car is clear of snow. I don't feel like I put a lot of work into it but I also didn't wait until the snow was frozen. What I'm saying is that it doesn't take long to shovel out.
Was it a Smart Car?
Was it a Smart Car?
Mmmkay
I shoveled three times today...10am, 4pm, and 10pm...on a small but heavily traveled street in Roslindale (I think we're an emergency artery because we were generally well plowed throughout the day). Two of the three times it was two of us doing it and it took us an hour each time. The people on my street and the surrounding streets were shoveling for about an hour as well. We're able-bodied, in our 20's and 30's. But we also made sure to not shovel in the street or screw any of our neighbors by shoveling in their directions. We were 2.5 ft from the car to the road with snow from the plows, and up to the top of the car, at 10am. Plus, I try to shovel as much of the front of the house as I can for my landlord who is busy with three young kids.
But maybe you're doing sarcasm wrong?
You're lucky
I spent 30 minutes shoveling yesterday before my back gave out. I tried tonight for 15 minutes until my back gave up again. I called a handy-man who had the rest done in 20 minutes. Keeping that dude on speed dial the rest of the Winter!
Parking restrictions
Seems to me the city could make the street-cleaning parking restrictions year round. In the winter, instead of street-cleaner trucks, send snow removal equipment.
My opinion of the Mayor I lower now. Ten hours? Please. What a joke.
He's on a roll
First Boston 2024, now this. One-term mayor, ya think?
I'm lodging my first Citizen Connect complaint
If the trash guys don't take the space savers next week.
I drive a Jeep and don't space save but the savers don't usually bug me much.
But there's no open places to make your own space and I don't want to deal with this nonsense for a month.
i don't pay much attention but aren't the trash guys contractors and not city DPW?
How is the city going to get them to throw out all the savers? they weren't picking many up in Dot last winter.
This is the defining issue
This is the defining issue that separates those who grew up in the city with those who didn't.
Yuppies: I grew up with driveways and my daddy would use the snowblower to get me out, so how dare you save your space?!
City folk: we've been doing this for decades. If you want to live in the city, deal with it.
The Mayor grew up in the City. It's obvious where he stands. Yuppie backfire... commence!!
Space savers started and
Space savers started and became more common under Menino. This isn't a decades old practice.
Wrong
I can remember space saving in the sixties.
I wrote the original comment.
I wrote the original comment.
Three decades ago, I was born (and raised in JP). We've been doing this since I've been alive.
It's only now "become a problem".
The numbers are different.
I grew up in the city on a street where the expectation was: you shoveled it, and didn't need space savers. There were open unshoveled areas available for a person who wanted to put in a little work instead of just pulling into the space you cleaned. We all knew which neighbor constantly did exactly that. We didn't however think we owned the space for weeks. It was just etiquette.
Now, with multiple cars per household, it is hard enough to find a spot on a normal day, much less one in the snow.
In a crowded city overstuffed with cars, there should not be the equivalent of an out of order/ closed/ be back in 10 hours / park here and I'll slash your tires sign on public spaces when people go to work.
Oh and the most pristine cars I saw on my walk were next to a large pile in the street on formerly clear passable roads. Can we have a public service announcement on this? It is undermining the plow progress.
FYI
Menino was mayor for 2 decadeS.
hmmmmm
It was common in Southie & parts of Dot, not the whole city.
Pandering
He's just pandering to the old time townies who think its their god given right to use a space saver. That's all. Nothing more, nothing less. Let's see if his pandering works out for him in the next election, some how I doubt that.
I keep saying this but Marty is more and more the mouth piece for just about everything wrong in Boston (space savers, townies, unions, and more)
Agreed
I wasn't a Walsh guy, but figured anything would be a breath of fresh air after Menino (not that he didn't do some good things for the city, I just didn't like his dictatorial style). Not quite. Walsh seems like Tommy Jr.
no, it is not so clear cut
I disagree - myself having been born and raised to use space savers in C town since forever. Now I would not consider saving the space I shovelled out, because it is just another example of the entitled behavior that is widespread in our community and has really gotten out of control. I am trying to raise my kids so they don't take or do what they want, despite the sake of convenience.
Yuppies move into a
Yuppies move into a neighborhood and want to change decades old traditions. In the North End, yuppies want to stop the feast of the Madonna. In Charlestown they want the USS Constitution to stop shooting off it's cannon at sunrise and sunset. In the South End they have successfully ended the tradition of marking your parking spot after it snows. Then to top it off, they move out to the suburbs to have kids in 3-5 years. If you don't like the quirks of a city neighborhood, don't move there in the first place.
Please
Can we just hold neighborhood-by-neighborhood referendums? (referenda? referendmata?)
In high-density neighborhoods (writing from central JP...), this kind of policy just makes life bad --> you dig out the space your car is in (okay, secret, I kinda enjoy digging snow), you dont put a space-saver down because that would make you a tool, and then you get no parking when you get home. As a bonus, there could be a space-saver in the spot you dug.
Nope
The people who benefit from space-saving, or who perceive that they do, will vote for it. Others will be screwed. There's a reason why we don't let people vote on other people's rights.
I'd be sympathetic to space savers
Except: a few years ago, I borrowed my friend's car while they were away. The day before I picked them up at the airport to give them the car back, it snowed quite a lot. I dug out the car, left the spot, and came back on the T to find someone had thrown a cone in the spot I'd cleared. So as someone who doesn't even own a car, screw you and screw your space savers. Move out to the country and get a driveway if you need a place of your own for your car. Until then, I'll just hope the inevitable first fatality in one of these contretemps comes soon so we can leave the Stone Age behind.
Wait, so you didn't move the
Wait, so you didn't move the cone?
No
A) I had no more car, so it wasn't my problem anymore
B) Because once John Q. Asshole "reserved" "his" spot, I didn't want to set some little old lady who might have otherwise been the beneficiary of my work to have her tires slashed and her vents urinated in because "his" "hard" "work" "shoveling" "his" spot was compromised by her seeing an open spot on a public street and thinking it might have been OK to park there
This is absolutely THE thing
This is absolutely THE thing I don't miss about parking in Boston.
I think the mayor's right, but...
There's no competition for parking spots on my street. (Yes, in Boston, I know, I'm lucky.) But if there was, I'd leave my car in a pile of snow and I wouldn't drive again until the next thaw.
Good luck to your...
Tires and brakes.
I shoveled out my space, an
I shoveled out my space, an empty space, and three neighbors in three hours, not "ten hours per space" -- and no, no space saving to be had. Completely foolish of the mayor to condone this behavior -- claiming a right to public space that no one else can "infringe" on and condoning littering, as well.
Maybe if Boston had some kind
Maybe if Boston had some kind of sensible way to plow the streets.
That requires getting all the
That requires getting all the cars OFF the streets. You'd have to give advance notice (via signs), then go in with scoops and dumptrucks (slow job)...if you did every street in the city like that, you wouldn't be done until spring.
I dunno, other cities in the
I dunno, other cities in the area seem to be able to pull off parking bans/alternate side of the street plowing just fine.
1) I don't believe the mayor
1) I don't believe the mayor is pandering to anyone. I think he grew up in the city and actually believes that people should be able to save spaces.
2) I understand that this has been a movement on this site but many many Bostonians support saving spaces. They are not crazy or selfish or cave dwellers, they are just doing what they have been doing for 30 + years.
3) Stop saying that this is a new practice, see #2.
4) I don't believe that the mayor meant that it would literally take 10 hrs to shovel a parking space, clearly it does not. But it takes more than the 45-1hr some of you are stating. There's about 2 ft of snow out there. It takes awhile.
5) I don't currently have a nickel in this quarter because I have a driveway. Just sharing my opinion.
1) I don't believe the mayor
Why can't both be true?
And when the reality on the ground changes such that your cherished 20 + years practice now infringes significantly on others, you are crazy or selfish or a cave dweller if you don't grow up, put on your big kid pants, and start sharing nicely.
An official city practice of enabling it is relatively new.
And yet we have people who actually timed themselves -- that's where those numbers come from. Are you calling them liars?
1. Can it be both? I guess,
1. Can it be both? I guess, but the pandering comment was meant to be offensive. I don't believe he is taking this stand so he can kiss some group's butt.
2. Just because you want people to change something quickly because you want them to doesn't mean they are wearing their little boy panties. Folks are just not changing their ways as fast as you would like.
3. Official, sure. But clearly an acceptable practice for a long long time.
4. I call it disagreeing, you call it lying.
Why can't plows get closer to sidewalk?
I live on an main road. No parking on the street during the blizzard. I total understand that but since there are no cars on the street, why does the snowplows still plow 10 ft away from the sidewalk?
In the past, they have come close to the sidewalk. It minimizes the amount of snow to shovel thus minimizes the space saver issues.
on Savin Hill Ave (in front
on Savin Hill Ave (in front of the mayor's house!), the "driving" portion of the street is plowed and the "parking" portion is completely unplowed. I'm pretty sure the entire point of the parking ban is that the parking area also gets plowed.
It doesn't matter what Marty has to say
I don't even live in the city so I have no dog in this fight.
Marty can say anything he wants regarding space savers, but no matter what he says, people are going to do what they're going to do. Those who feel entitled to use space savers will continue to do so unless Marty sends out an army of garbage trucks to continuously pick up the space savers. Whether you think that is a good use of tax dollars is a whole other issue.
Maybe an army of trucks would be needed at first.
That would diminish over time, as retaliators started realizing they were vandalizing the cars of (to say nothing of committing violence against) innocent people who didn't recognize spaces as previously saved. The fact that it's a difficult problem doesn't mean we should concede it as hopeless from the get-go.
I also think there are other steps that need to be taken to relieve the pressure on resident spaces, maybe like limiting the number of permits per household. Tacitly condoning vigilante behavior because some neighborhoods are inured to it is an abjuration of the Mayor's responsibilities to the citizenry. I understand his political motivations, but I can't support them.
Absurd!
I wasn't going to comment because I think it is all so ridiculous but I have noticed since this announcement, I now see space savers for 2hr parking spots....I think Marty has done the residents a disservice by supporting this craziness and it is now out of control!!! Not to mention, even when there is no snow, if you leave a parking spot in a crowded neighborhood you might need to drive around to find a spot when you return....so why now with snow, do residents get to save their parking spots?!? It makes no sense at all.
Oh and while I am ranting, why is it acceptable for cars to park next to snow banks IN THE TRAVEL LANE!? Driving in this city is nuts....and with the added snow it is beyond frustrating.
Rant over.