Curley Center administrator placed on leave as city investigates drowning death of young boy
UPDATE: Gofundme page set up to help Kyzr Willis's family.
Mayor Walsh said this afternoon the administrator of the Curley Center at Carson Beach is on paid leave as the city investigates both what happened to Kyrzr Willis, 7, and what the city can do to keep kids safe in its summer drop-in and camp facilities.
"This is just a horrible day," Walsh said at a press conference.
Police and Boston Center for Youth and Families are still trying to piece together what happened to Kyzr between roughly 2:15 p.m., when a lifeguard saw him come out of the water, and roughly 2:45 p.m., when he was declared missing. Police Commissioner William Evans said his body was found around 7 p.m. about 15 yards offshore.
Walsh said that yesterday, there were 56 kids at the Curley Center drop-in program and about 28 BCYF workers watching after them.
"Thousands of families entrust their kids every single day to us," he said. "And we take this trust very very seriously."
Walsh said he hopes to have an initial review of safety protocols at the 36 Boston Center for Youth and Families facilities that host programs for kids.
He said the Curley Center will re-open tomorrow for adults and on Monday for kids.
Ad:
Comments
Maybe start with No Texting
Maybe start with No Texting while watching kids at the beach rule and have more adult supervisors watching over the teen counselors. I don't know why this tragedy happened but I do know what I see with my own eyes.
I think you're more than
I think you're more than likely correct.
Our "summer playground" wasn't watching our kids
Several moms had doubts about the security of the summer playground (we had thought it was a camp) our kids were at. We didn't feel like they would notice if kids vanished. The next day the summer playground was supposed to take the kids to the lake. They decided to test the camp. One mom walked off with her friend's 7 year old girl. The camp didn't notice for 7 hours. The girl's mom came back to pick up her daughter. The camp called for her on the radio for several minutes. They had no idea she was gone. Fortunately she was fine and the girl's mom really knew her daughter was with a friend, but the camp staff was clueless. The administration stressed that they were a "summer playground" and not a camp and that the policy is that the kids are fee to leave with anyone, anytime, and the written policy says they do not do sign in/sign out and the parent has the responsibility to stress attendance expectations with their child. These places should not exist if they cannot guarantee the kids are secure. No parents who send their kids to these places realize the risk they are taking. No parent would risk their child's safety or knowingly leave them essentially without real supervision. They should be shut down if their policies and security are so lax. P.S. Several moms pulled their kids of of the MD "summer playground".
What about parenting?
First off..
So THEY KNEW the kids were unsupervised and could come and go as they please. It goes back to PARENTING. You know, checking out the "camp" or "playground" BEFORE hand to see what supervision was like and what not. But no, we're too quick to blame the program, when it was CLEAR BEFORE THEY SIGNED UP THAT THIS WAS THEIR POLICY.
Sorry I have little sympathy for the parents. Yeah it's sad their kid died, but its called do your homework on where you are sending your kids. Don't expect a level of security unless you've done the work yourself to scope it out.
What's even MORE disgusting is that this family.... not even a day after their kid died.. and the body isn't even cold, they are on WBZ tonight clamoring how "someone has to pay for this". And they are talking a lawsuit. Disgusting. Your child isn't even cold yet, and you're looking to place the blame somewhere other than yourselves. DO YOUR HOMEWORK FIRST.
And we wonder why these programs are happening less and less. And probably after this, the MD program will be dismantled because no one wants to be a brunt for lawsuits. This is why we can't have programs like this anymore, slacker parents who expect the world when in reality they are getting a shoe box. And we wonder why things cost so much these days, things like day programs.. because of the liability insurance that has to be taken out on these programs. Small groups don't want to pay nor want to deal with this crap. And I see why.
Go ahead flame away. I'm just tired of the "this is why we can't have nice things" because of slacker parents who are lawsuit happy.
You have no idea
Grief does odd things to people - especially when they have cameras and microphones shoved in their faces demanding to know "what are you going to do about this"? If you were grown up enough, you'd know that.
I get the impression that you have "never had to knock on wood" even. Get some more life experience and lay the fuck off these people. They have been dealt a tough blow. This is not supposed to happen. There is no script for what they are going through, nor should their be.
No Swirl
You have no idea about me. You just brushed with a broad stroke, And you're clearly wrong.
First off, I'm not that much younger than you, so I'm well grown up enough to know all about this.
Secondly, You have no idea about me, who I am, what I am about, and what I've been thru. Maybe if you did, you wouldn't make such comments like that because you would fully understand that I have knocked on wood more times than I want to admit.
Thirdly. This is the internet on a website that allows comments. Duh. We're suppose to do this. And frankly, I have just as much right to air my opinion about a story as you do.
Well whoever came up with the
Well whoever came up with the idea to have an all day summer space for unsupervised 7-8 year olds on the beach is an idiot. So what are the adult workers in this space getting paid for??? It doesn't make any sense! You're better of dropping your kids of at the park away from water and hoping for the best. Stupid idea and a disaster waiting to happen. Oh wait it did happen.
Were you there?
Obviously, something went horribly wrong. But stop making assumptions based on no direct knowledge of what went on there.
I suspect we'll find out soon enough what happened - even if the city does want to sweep this under a rug (and I've yet to see signs of this), this is the kind of story that reporters are not going to forget.
no assumptions being made
no assumptions being made Adam. I attend this beach often and have seen with my own eyes exactly what I am posting. Like I said I don't know what happened on this day in this case but I am not assuming that the texting and lack of supervision is happening. I have better things to do than to stir the pot. I was and still am honestly concerned.
Brushed with a broad stroke?
Go reread your hateful anti-parent screed if you want a good example of that.
You clearly have no clue, or you would not have typed what you did.
Yes we do have the right to
Yes we do have the right to express our opinions. But this site is monitored by Adam and his jurisdiction overrides our rights to expess such opinionswhich means some don't get posted. Oh well.
I feel for the parents who have just lost their son
And I agree with an investigation into this tragic incident needs to be done. However, I do not agree with immediately making a statement like "somebody's got to pay for this" - in other words "We're looking for a big cash settlement."
But, unfortunately, that's the new American way "Who can we sue and how much can we get."
Having someone pay for it
Having someone pay for it doesn't necessarily mean that they are thinking of suing at this point. It could mean someone should lose their job. These parents are distraught let's cut them a little slack.
I hope you never suffer a loss like theirs
I cannot imagine the grief they are going through - they drop their son off for a day at the beach and he winds up dead.
I don't think grief is the new American way. I think immediately criticizing parents who have just experienced the most horrible thing imaginable is the American way.
Modern cynicism
"I think immediately criticizing parents who have just experienced the most horrible thing imaginable is the American way."
No, the American Way is to help those around you, the worse it is, the better people respond. Occupied building fires are typical examples. Every week we see someone in a burning building knocking on doors to help other occupants.
I think it's more the anonymous internet way. Folks say things that they would never say to your face.
This is from the gofundme page they set up. I did a screen cap, so if it gets pulled, I have it. I shit you not, "Either this is a FaceSwap image of the boy or a scam going on. The boy has a mans eyes, mouth and neck placed over his face, and the color does not match. If this is a genuine post, I encourage the organizer to use an actual photo of the boy, and not a Face Swap photo."
It's the news photo...
Just wow. Wow. Poor family has to see that? Jeebus. I mean really. It makes snarkygrrl's remark about me being dumb enough to stick my bare hand in the face of an opossum quite tame. (I didn't, by the way)
The ocean doesn't take prisoners. It looks like they had a bunch of kids in the Youth program watching the little kids. Hey, they tried, but it isn't that simple. Pro-trained lifeguards in tall chairs are there for a reason. They know what to look for. I have no idea what the setup was, so I can't criticize, but something went wrong. Way fucking wrong.
What the F*&^% are you talking about?
That is the picture of the kid, enlarged. And you have the balls to say it is a "scam!" Cripes, Jesus.
If you believe the "American Way" is to help those around you, you might want to rethink your analysis.
And, by the way, there are a lot of good folks who go out of the way to help others in this country. And there are others who screw others, who are assw*&les, who are judgemental and mean pr*&ks. It is not a "way" but the best and worst in human nature.
Reading comprehension.
....
Maybe
It's not the best idea to stick a camera and a microphone right in the face of a parent in this situation, but I appreciate that the local TV news needs a little local action to break up their parade of car chases in LA.
I believe that is about
Hoping you can pass an AIDS test .
Not how you would act when your child dies .
"Yeah it's sad their kid died, but"
Reflect on what you just said.
Is there really a good time, or a good reason, to say those words?
I don't think so.
And is this the best we can
And is this the best we can do for low income city kids? Give working parents no choice but to take a risk with their children. I would hope that the City of Boston can do better than that. Is a sign in/sign out sheet going to drain the budget???
.
the drop-in camp outside Roslindale/West Roxbury YMCA has a sign-in sheet and a person sitting there at a table. The director in charge is an adult. She has a cell phone. Teens who work there do not permit anyone in the park to engage with the kids. They're polite but insistent. They have the two basketball courts (fenced in) reserved from morning to 6pm daily for camp. ,
Actually...
I went to one of these summer camps in South Boston growing up. Everyone in the neighborhood did. Regardless of how officials are presenting it- it was described as a summer camp with camp counsellors. We were monitored, played with and counted.
Also, it was affordable. I believe the BYCC camps still require a fee to sign up and go. My friends that were counsellors at the Curley were paid to supervise the campers.
It is a tremendously tragic situation where a young boy died. Placing the blame on the family and judging their reaction is highly inappropriate. Regardless of your own tragedies, lay off.
No parent would leave their child at an unsupervised camp for the day. To continuously call it that is insulting and wrong. FYI- accountability in these circumstances is essential for healing. Based on the judgements throughout your comment, I can almost guarantee you disagree. But today, I'm holding you accountable for your hateful words.
The parents
You really are a clueless moron that boy lost his life and regardless you shouldnt have a program like that at the beach thats like playing with matches at a gas station something is bound to happen and clearly the city thinks differently they suspended somebody and regardless you cant have programs like this these days because there are to many crazy people in this world
Sign of the times
It's s shame things like this have changed. When I was a kid (not terribly long ago) there was little fear of abductions even in urban areas. (They happened about as often as today but people didn't fear them as they do now.) If a kid left without permission, the parents would be mad at the kid, not the facility. I used to spend lots of time alone or playing with neighbors when I was that kids age.
Things change, true. But it hardly seems productive in the long run when parents expect schools and camps to have prison type security and TSA style identity checks.
It's horrible and sad what happened to the poor child but I'm willing to believe this was a tragic accident and not criminal negligence.
Agreed
I agree with your post 100% This is what I was getting at. It all falls back to parenting or lack there of it.
And I agree with this. It was an accident, and the parents have no ground to stand on for a lawsuit.
So we are paying people to
So we are paying people to use their cell phones/text at these drop off camps for what??? have you ever been at this site on the beach? If you have I think you would think differently.
Cybah my friend
please look up in loco parenti.
You have no idea what
You have no idea what happened, no understanding of what the parents are going through, and no stake in this. Maybe you should consider what kind of person you are to make the sorts of statements you feel qualified to make. I for one am hopeful you never find anyone willing to reproduce your DNA.
One cannot blame the parents on the boy's unfortunate drowning.
The boy's drowning death at the camp in question should not have happened. Something went awry somewhere, and it's not the parents of the deceased boy that're at fault for the boy's drowning death. Something was clearly lacking in the supervision policies in the camp in question, which needs to be rectified...right away, if only to prevent more tragedies like this from occurring again in the future.
Tragic all around.
Not only the death of the child, but the rush to judgement. How quickly the parents are demanding that someone must pay. How quickly the counsellors are blamed. How quickly it's determined the city is guilty of negligence. Accidents happen. People die. It's not always someone's fault.
Are you kidding me? People
Are you kidding me? People die? I'm sorry kids don't go to camp and die very often. 7 years old. He was not responsible for his own safety and wellbeing the adults in charge were. If a child died in a more expensive camp in the suburbs would you think the same? Would the parents be to blame? I think absolutely not!
That's offensive.
Why are you trying to turn this into a class issue? Does everything have to be rich vs. poor, or urban vs. suburban?
If the reports are true and the there was one employee for every two kids, that seems a reasonable ratio to me. And maybe there are additional safeguards that could be put in place to help prevent future tragedies in the future.
But, yes, as I said in my original post, "Accidents happen. People die. It's not always someone's fault." What exactly do you disagree with? The only surefire way to prevent a kid from drowning at the facility is to close the facility. Is that what we want?
wtf does this have to do with
wtf does this have to do with the situation reported here? The parents in this story lost their child because a CITY RUN camp was negligent. your unrelated anecdote is blaming the victims for your own shoddy camp experience. nobody asked you.
These camps are poorly supervised
My friend's son started work at one of these drop in camps a few years ago and he said it was a nightmare. They never knew how many kids were coming to camp on any given day. They did not know the kids who were coming. The staff were poorly trained high school kids. There were a lot of behavior problems with the kids. The camp was free and her son said people used it like free babysitting. He ended up quitting because it was just chaos.
A few years ago I signed my daughter up for a low cost YMCA summer camp. Day one she came home without her shoes (she was 5 years old) - she lost them. Day two she came home without her clothes. Day three she had a sunburn. I applied sunscreen in the morning and sent some with her in her backpack, but she was only 5 years old and she needed help reapplying the sunscreen and no one would help her. Day four she came home with pink eye and there was no day five - we were done. One of the other mothers said she went early to the swimming area (Hale Reservation) to pick up her daughter, and all she saw were a bunch of teenagers on towels talking to each other, or on their cell phones. No one was watching the kids.
That was the last time I ever sent my daughter to a camp like that. Now she goes to a camp where the counselors are all adults (mostly teachers) and the assistant counselors are college students. This camp is much better at supervising the children, everything comes home every day, and they help apply sunscreen. The camp is very expensive, but her safety is worth every penny.
I hate to say it, but you get what you pay for, and if it is free or cheap then don't expect much.
It is a tragedy that this little boy died, and I am sure that lack of proper supervision is what led to his drowning.
Parents need to checkout the programs they send their children to and make sure they are of high quality, with solid supervision.
They are high school kids
As you say, you get what you pay for. There is no excuse for why the little boy should have died, though I'm surprised at the number of posters who are critical of these programs yet acknowledge the staff is largely teenagers.
Perhaps the city should fund these programs to the point of being able to hire only adults with extensive experience and training but it's hard to see where the money would come from. For many, there is simply no option to pay for an expensive camp. It's either these programs or give up a needed job.
Again, this isn't to say the poor child deserved to be let go unsupervised. But there needs to be some acknowledgment that these programs provide a valuable service to many parents without other options as well as providing reasonable jobs to teens who otherwise might not find work. If these programs close due to lack of funding for adults it's hard to see how Boston is better off as a whole.
Nope
I agree with your first statement. You DO get what you pay for. And I'm sure since it was a MD program, I'm sure it was next to free to attend.
Secondly, as far as "Supervision". WBZ reported these facts.
There was 56 Kids
There were 28 "councilors"
That means there were two kids to each councilor? How much supervision do you need? Thats a VERY high ratio. How high do you want it to be? 1 to 1 ? by that point, you might as well hire a nanny.
Okay
So why are you blaming the parents for everything, again?
At least you aren't going on and on about "urban welfare cases who should be working three minimum wage jobs while 24/7 watching their kids" while saying it. I'll give you that.
I feel sorry for you and cybah.
This spat is reprehensible, and you especially just can't help yourself. How unhappy are you in your life to act this way?
blame the victims
"you get what you pay for" is an absurd comment. I can't believe you think any adult in America never mind Boston would choose a inexpensive camp believing they were rolling the dice with their kids safety. When the City of Boston runs a drop-in day camp we all have every right to expect the people working there, specifically the adults, will deliver our kids back in the same condition. Marty will try to bury the facts and make it go away. Hopefully the press will get the facts. Until there are personal consequences for not doing your job, it will continue periodically.
Learn to read.
Then tell me where in my post I blamed a victim. I'm going to assume you were hammered, based on the timing of your incoherent rant. That's the most bark table read I can give you.
If a summer camp for city kids is going to hire teenagers,
then there should be adult overseers (18 and over), that supervise the teens to make sure that they're doing their job correctly, plus the high school kids should be better-trained to begin with..
As someone who runs a similar
As someone who runs a similar program this is tough. We are much smaller (only about 13 kids right now with 2 adult staff and 6 or 7 teens on any given day) and only half day but free. A child's tragic death during summer camp does not fall on the parents. At the end of the day if it is because of bad communication, under trained teen staff,the student her/himself, or just oversight it falls on the camp administrators. I know how easy it can be to lose track of a kid and I'm sure it happens all of the time with little or no consequence (it has happened to me in my program) but that is our job and it is crucial especially in dangerous situations. As frustrating it is to sometimes see teen employees paying more attention to each other/their phones/other distractions than the students it is our job to remind them. My group was at Carson yesterday and I must have counted my (albeit small) group 50 times in 3 hours even if I was sure they were all there, even with some parents present.The teen counsellors are staff but adults should know their limits and have reasonable expectations. While this may be a tragic accident the responsibility falls on the adults in charge of running this camp and accounting for students. Calling the parents at fault and saying "you get what you pay for" is disgraceful and comes from position of privilege.
Man, I just can't get over
Man, I just can't get over the hatefulness on this thread. When j was a young mom and lived in Boston I sent my kid to a camp that we could afford. I knew it wasn't awesome but we had to work and had no support system. To think that if a tragedy had befallen my daughter you armchair blame gamers would have taken me to task for bad parenting. The real crime is that now our circumstances have improved and we are lucky enough to live in a town that provides cheap and safe summer recreation camps run by teachers from the school. Of course it's only accessible to the upper middle class families who don't truly need it. I am so horribly sorry for this family and for the way their tragedy is compounded by such inhuman thoughtlessness.
Please Read the specifics
Such a loss is a terrible tragedy.
But let's read carefully what is being conveyed.
There is a program called a "Summer program" or "camp" that is specifically licensed and which has specific sign-in and out policies with full day care credentials.
The BCYF department has also been operating "summer drop in" sessions all over the city for kids 6-18 years but it is STRESSED over and over that this is not a babysitting service nor summer camp. All the literature says this. It is a program where neighborhood kids can come in play and then leave, in their own neighborhoods.
If parents are bringing their kids there and leaving them unattended, they are misunderstanding the program. It is very likely that the staff explained this. Any drop in program that I have experience with is very careful to do this.
BUT - and this is a big BUT - if the kid walks in from the neighborhood they will be accepted to play and be watched, but they can leave anytime and go home. Many of these drop in programs also provide a breakfast and lunch free for any kids that wants to stop in fo ra meals as well.
This is set up as a community service.
If parents want a fully licensed and secured summer camp program, those are also available with fully certified (specifically trained) child care staff.
I also think it is a darn shame that the administrator of that facility was put on leave. Such a person rarely leaves their office and is not on the front lines to watch kids. But our society needs a human sacrifice when things like this happens. It was not that person's fault what so ever, bit often just to show that something was done, the City will take disciplinary action just to appease people who need an outward sign.
This year the number of citywide drop in locations was cut back drastically.
Psychic prediction... due to this there will likely be no drop in locations fo rkids next year.
Maybe there will be more staffed and certified summer camps but the city cannot provide that with who and what they have. It will have to be people specifically hired fo rthat job and licensed accordingly, and that will cost you $$$.
Here's a thought... Last year the Healy Playground in Roslindale had such a drop in session. They mat in the play area by the swimming pool. Most of the kids walked in from the neighborhood, all ages 6-12 on average. When the kids got tired of playing there with supervision, or it got too hot, they could leave and go home. What happens if the kid leaving gets hit by a car?
Same thing really. In this case the child wandered away from the Curley Center and went under the water.
Again, this is a terrible loss of a beautiful child, but people need to know what they are getting into here and what is being provided... and what is not. Sadly, now a senior administrator is in deep sneakers and that person was not at fault.
Don't care what the stupid brochure says.
If kids as young as 6 are being dropped off then it is effectively a baby sitting service. Doesn't matter what is STRESSED.
What on earth are they thinking running a program with children so young where supervision is not a thing? It's amazing we don't hear about more tragedies happening with the young kids all the time.
This program needs to majorly be revamped. It's shocking to me it exists.
I read your post and my
I read your post and my thoughts are...I don't think the teen counselors are at fault here but the adults in charge of them could do a better job at setting guidelines when caring for small children. Another thought is who in the City of Boston thinks it's ok to have an unsupervised camp on a beach??? And why is it ok to register a 7 year old from Dorchester into a South Boston camp knowing that they would have to travel a long way home if they left? I think this type of camp should be for older children that can make their way around safely. Changes need to be made to this drop in camp.
Dorchester!
How dare they bring a DORCHESTER kid to a SOUTHIE beach!
Even if the state runs it ...
Huh??? I don't think that you
Huh??? I don't think that you understood my post. I'm not complaining about a Dorchester child attending the camp. Read slowly. My point was that how can the city expect a 6-8 year old to safely navigate to and from a south Boston camp site when the journey home is in Dorchester. A drop in camp with no supervision that lets kids attend different sites should be put aside for older children. Younger children should be sign in and sign out by an adult. Get it?
Google Maps is thataway -->
The family lives on Trull Street. Go look at a map and see how far that is from Carson Beach.
Also, it's 2016. Dorchester kids are allowed to use Carson Beach, which, again, if you look at a map, is literally right on the South Boston/Dorchester line.
And please stop with the "unsupervised" stuff. Obviously, yes, something went horribly wrong. But there were, according to the city, roughly 1 worker for every 2 kids. That's not "unsupervised."
HOW TO SPOT SOMEONE DROWNING/IN DISTRESS:
DROWNING IN REAL LIFE DOESN'T LOOK LIKE MOVIES. KNOW THE SIGNS, SAVE A LIFE.
1. They can’t call for help—she has to be able to breathe before she can speak. When a person is drowning, her mouth sinks below and reappears above the surface of the water. There isn’t time for her to exhale, inhale, and call out.
2. They can’t wave for help either. A drowning person instinctively extends her arms to the sides and presses down to lift her mouth out of the water; a child may extend her arms forward. She can’t use her arms to move toward a rescuer or reach for rescue equipment.
3. They remain upright in the water, with no evidence of kicking. She can struggle for only 20 to 60 seconds before going under.
4. Their eyes are glassy, unable to focus, or closed.
5. Their face may be hard to see; hair may be over forehead or eyes.
6. Their Head is low in the water, with mouth at water level; head may be tilted back with mouth open. A child’s head may fall forward.
7. They are quiet. Children playing in the water make noise. When they get quiet, you need to get to them and find out why.
8. They don’t seem in distress. Sometimes the most important indicator that someone is drowning is that she doesn’t look like she’s drowning. She may just seem to be looking up at the sky, shore, pool deck, or dock. Ask her, “Are you all right?” If she can answer at all, she probably is. If she returns a blank stare, you may have less than 30 seconds to get to her.
Thanks for the heads up regarding signs of drowning, anon.
This is valuable information that should go viral and directors and staffpeople (i. e. counselors, Assistant counselors, and lifeguards and other water-front workers, including high school kids in training for such jobs or working them) should definitely know and be aware of.
Thanks for posting it.
My sister took a water-safey course and became a certified
Water Safety Aid person, and an ace swimmer. She mentioned that there were several options that could be used, if and when saving a person that was endanger of drowning was possible, although there are rare instances when it isn't possible. They were as follows:
Reach--Exttend a rope, or even a piece of cloth or pole to the victim if s/he is close enough
Throw-Throw a life tube on a rope for the victim
Row: Row out to get the victim, extend an oar to him/her to get in the boat.
Go- Swim out to get the victim (last resort.
No: A rare occasion when it's totally impossible to save the victim.