Hey, there! Log in / Register
Boston school superintendent quits
By adamg on Fri, 06/22/2018 - 4:54pm
WBZ reports that Tommy Chang, Boston school superintendent since 2015, is leaving his job. The Globe reports that Chang, who came here from Los Angeles, is quitting even though he doesn't have another job lined up.
Chang issued a short statement:
I am in active negotiations with the Boston School Committee for a mutual parting of ways.
Neighborhoods:
Topics:
Free tagging:
Ad:
Comments
ICE ICE BABY
Tommy is leaving because of a lawsuit where BPS turned over information to ICE and a student was deported. I have a feeling that BPS has been turning over information about students to law enforcement agencies for years. If an investigation reveals that this is standard practice heads should roll if students privacy rights have been violated.
We'll see
He didn't quit over the Boston Latin/Black Lives matter and that involved an investigation by the US Attorney's office and possibly getting thrown under the bus by the mayor.
Custodial fund misuse
And we shouldn’t forget the misuse of student custodial funds that resulted in a hefty fine to the IRS. While the alleged misuse is said to have occurred before his tenure, it was his district when the fine was paid.
I see this as likely a “three strikes and he’s out” situation.
NotoriousVOG:
NotoriousVOG:
Late spring cleaning..?
After the other 2 resignations (did they jump or were they pushed?), you have to wonder if Marty is responding to criticism & is trying to shake things up a bit? No idea.
But without public schools
Who's going to get some kid kicked out of his/her home?
Athens of America my ass. This is a great city if you're a single adult like me. I would never in a million years enroll a child in a public school here, and this city is the damned pinnacle of American intellectual curiosity. Kids deserve a better education than the one I got in public schools.
Totally agree. The lawsuit --
Totally agree. The lawsuit -- and what will come out -- was the final straw.
That said, I support the federal governments effort to crack down on undocumented immigrants, and see Marty Walsh's sanctuary city demands as an attempt to curry favor with the national Democratic Party, so when time comes for another job, he can count on its support.
Students privacy rights are
Students privacy rights are violated when a public school system shares data with law enforcement?
That's not how privacy works.
Yes it is
Google FERPA
No, it's not
Google "FERPA law enforcement exception"
Read what you googled
If the police want information on students they have to have a warrant.
That warrant can't be a fishing expedition, either - it applies only to those named in it.
New Superintendent Should Be......
... Lynne Mooney Teta.
No me digas
¡Que sorpresa!
Is that politician-speak for "I fired his lame ass?"
Do as we say
No, it reads we need someone who is going to continue our agenda of disenfranchising predominately students of color in under-served, low performing schools.
Thought Tommy Chang was having a bad day...
then I read about Charlie Baker and Hanley Ramirez.
Chang's farewell letter
Cites accomplishments, but doesn't say why he's leaving right this second.
Gee...
think Tommy wrote that or one of the poor saps that has to teach Mahty Hooked On Phonics did ?
I hate the modern format of
I hate the modern format of resignation letters / farewell emails where you humblebrag everything you worked on.
It was so much nicer when all you had to write was "I had fun. Will miss everyone so much. Keep in touch!"
Could also be pressure from...
Release of data regarding Harvard admissions (Latin) and he has already provided it or perhaps doesn't want his name attached to eventual access to it...
Had no choice
BPS lawyers asked to be excluded from that suit; judge said nope.
You know what Kiss 108 does?
They pipe in Ryan Seacrest five hours a day. I caught one of his talk breaks on the way to work today. It was pablum, but it was no less relevant than anything that a live, local person would have said.
Rather than pay a full salary and benefits to a local DJ, Kiss 108/iHeart Radio simply runs recorded patter from LA (now from NY since he started doing Live with Kelly Ripa), and the station still sounds great. You get celebrity/entertainment news from a guy who actually talks to celebrities instead of from some guy/girl just quoting Perez Hilton. It's called "voicetracking."
Now, all I hear about when I read about Boston schools is how great Latin is, and how poor so many of the others are. So, when do the Latin teachers start voicetracking into other classrooms in Boston? Stick an intern into the classroom to handle discipline and giving the tests, and play recorded lessons from the best teachers.
It would appear that the number of good school personnel is finite. If we can't keep this guy around for even half a decade, then's what's the point? He got to live in Boston and make a quarter million dollars a year. Sounds like a sweet life to me.
What return did the Boston schools get on that investment? When are school systems going to be built around this uncomfortable truth that there just aren't as many people as we would like who can do this job and do it well?
Respectfully
With all due respect for someone who committed so much time to setting up this analogy, I think you’d be hard pressed to find many people in education who believe it all comes down to an impersonal lecture, some tests, and direct discipline.
Casting
Boston Latin is good because of casting, not because of pedagogy. They skim off the top 10% of Boston students, then haze them until a third of them leave. You want to pipe in lessons, do it from a school known for the quality of its teaching, not for the cruelty of its traditions. It wouldn't benefit students in other schools at all to listen to disembodied BLS teachers fulminate and cuss their way through a class period.
Some of the kids at BLS thrive, but most of the kids don't, and the outcomes are unimpressive beyond the top 4% who go to Harvard. Few of the grads go anywhere they wouldn't be able to go without BLS, and most grads still go to state schools or community colleges. The kids who ditch BLS probably do just as well as the kids who stay.
Don't believe the hype. BLS is as much as cult as it is a school. It's middle-of-the pack for high-pressure public schools, not exceptional. The difference is that most of the other schools that are just as good (e.g. Lexington, Brookline, Wellesley, Newton North...) take all comers and don't haze kids until they drop out. So pedagogically they're probably accomplishing more.
BLS dropout rate today...
... is nowhere near one-third. In fact, it is currently close to zero percent:
https://masscharterschools.org/sites/default/files/docs/releases/final_a...
The rest of your comment is equally factual...
https://www.usnews.com/education/best-high-schools/massachusetts/distric...
Lol
You know as well as I do that kids only get counted as "dropouts" if they don't go to any other school. The third of the kids who start BLS in 7th grade and end up graduating from a different school aren't "dropouts" as listed in that table. You're a smart guy. You couldn't figure that out?
And US News as the sole arbiter of school quality? It's a great shortcut, and it has the benefit of being easy to game. But there are other rankings.
https://www.niche.com/k12/search/best-public-high-schools/s/massachusetts/
I replaced the drop out statistics...
... with attrition rates -- 2 percent not 33.
BLS is hardly perfect -- but your sliming of it is outright dishonest.
Innumeracy
If this is the best you can do, you should not be defending whoever taught you math in high school. Pulling in odd statistics that don't quite match the question at hand doesn't bolster your argument.
Just stop and think about it for a moment. 450 kids start in 7th grade. If 97% of them graduated six years later, there would be no B track at BLS, and a lot more kids would graduate every year.
Per the DOE, only 417 of the starting 450 kids remained in 7th grade this year, and only 380 of last year's 7th graders continued on to 8th.
http://profiles.doe.mass.edu/profiles/student.aspx?orgcode=00350560&orgt...
If you have a strong, fact-based case to make, you don't have to make up things.
If you don't like attrition rate...
... here's the mobility rate (including churn): http://profiles.doe.mass.edu/mobility/default.aspx?orgcode=00350560&fyco...
Making things up? {rest of what I feel like saying deleted}
Innumeracy
Context as well
Not knowing the definitions involved enables a whole lot of different scenarios to explain the statistics
Let's assume that some fraction of Latin students might be children of some graduate student at one of Boston and Cambridge's many institutions of higher ed
Suppose that grad student finishes his/her degree and is accepted into a post-doc program in California -- and takes the family with him/herself-- how is the loss of the corresponding BLS student counted
My own situation several decades ago is an example I was a graduate student and then a member of the research staff at the U of Texas Austin -- our daughter was a student in a prestigious private high school in Austin. We moved up here and she followed in the middle of the school year. An "attit" would have occured in the school in Austin and a corresponding gain occurred in Lexington High School.
Pray-tell who keeps track of that kind of "transaction" -- Google?
anecdata
I knew a guy who moved his family from Newton to Boston just so his kid could attend BLS. I guess he should have asked you first.