Volkswagen sues Revere for letting tow company sell off car the company was still financing
For the second time in four years, a car company has sued Revere for the way the city let a tow company sell off a car without first notifying the car company, which still had a lien on it.
The last time, in a case involving Honda, a federal judge ruled that the practice was unconstitutional. In its own federal suit, filed in US District Court in Boston, Volkswagen makes a similar claim. In addition to Revere, the company is suing the tow company, the man the tow company sold the car to and the Registry of Motor Vehicles, in an effort to get either the car or the money it says it's still owed on it.
At issue is a 2022 Audi whose owner VW says defaulted on his loan payments in August, 2022, less than a month after he bought the car. In September, 2022, Revere Police had Atlantis Towing tow the car off a Revere road. The company then applied for and got a lien on the car from the Registry, which, after the initial owner didn't pay up for the towing and storage, it sold, according to VW's complaint.
Volkswagen says that by failing to notify it the car had been towed and then sold, both the city and Atlantis violated its property and due-process rights. In 2020, a federal judge concluded the state law that lets tow companies sell off cars like Atlantis allegedly did is unconstitutional because it never afforded Honda the right to protest the sale of a car it had a stake in - and ordered Revere to pay Honda the value of the car.
In Volkswagen's case, the company is also going after the person who purchased the car from Atlantis, saying that when it traced the car to him, it demanded he give it up and he refused, and it wants its car back.
Last month, a bank filed a similar suit against Boston and the RMV.
Attachment | Size |
---|---|
Complete complaint | 834.07 KB |
Ad:
Comments
how are towed cars with liens
handled in other states?
Good
Everything about this is so shady. Also, how did the tow company sell a car without the title? There was a lien on the vehicle so the loan holder had the title.
I think that's where the RMV comes in
They have paperwork to give tow companies titles to towed cars, according to the complaint.
Seems like a pretty obvious RMV fail
It makes sense to allow someone (tow lot, garage, municipality, etc.) to take over the title of an abandoned vehicle which is in their possession, but the RMV certainly should not process the transfer of that title to another party for consideration (i.e. selling it) unless the lien is satisfied first.
Indeed it's strange
Especially since the RMV is well known to be staffed by people with unimpeachable character. I hear they might even get their best from the BPD Evidence department.
What could possibly go wrong?
What could possibly go wrong?
The Government taking private property
I read about that being a no no somewhere